FINALLY. Another recipe. It’s been a while… but this has been one of the coolest things I’ve ever baked. It was my second time EVER working with yeast and it was definitely not as intimidating as I thought it would be. The first time I used yeast I made pizza dough and that’s such a distant memory… This second experience working with yeast was somehow more scary— I was terrified the dough wouldn’t rise properly because I messed up on the flour proportions and mixed some of the ingredients out of order. But it was such a great experience overall!
I first saw the recipe on Elissa from 17andbaking a few weeks ago and I was determined to try it. I feel like I’ve been in a rut of baking very normal sweets… the run-of-the-mill cookies, quick-breads, muffins and cupcakes. Nothing particularly… crazy. This proved to be less of a challenge than I thought it would be, but it was definitely time-consuming. It is pretty much an all day project! I loved every minute of it though and even created a warm area in my apartment (my room with the heater on) for the dough to rise. I definitely would make this again but with a few adjustments….
This was the result :

As you can see, the crust is pretty brown and had a thicker and harder crust than I would have liked. I think it may have been because of the dark pan I used, but it wasn’t really too much of a problem. I’ve heard that William-Sonoma’s gold-touched pans are ideal for baking because they don’t cause extra and unwanted browning, but they can be a little pricey. Another thing that I’ll be adjusting the next time I make this is cut down on the amount of butter used for the filling. I don’t own a pastry brush, so this may be the cause of the extra butter, but I find that hard to believe… as I had twice the amount of butter than I needed! I ended up pouring the leftover butter into the pan, hoping that the dough would somehow absorb the buttery goodness… but I think it simply contributed to a more browned crust. One thing I changed this time is substitute grapefruit zest for the orange zest since that’s all I had on hand. I couldn’t really taste the grapefruit so I’m assuming it doesn’t make that much of a difference. Another thing that I noticed was that the bread was slightly more dense than I would have desired, so I think I would increase the rising time for both rising sessions. A lighter loaf is inarguably more heavenly! A lot of icing also dripped down the sides when I drizzled it on, so I’d probably try to split the layers while it’s still warm to insure more icing in the actual cake rather than a light coating on the top.
All in all, I’ll be making this again when I have a free day… but first, home-made thin mints, upside-down apple cake, pumpkin pie, banana creme pie, and pastry dough. :)
Happy Baking!
-Mandy
P.S. I didn’t post the recipe here because I felt like it was too long… but you can check it out at Elissa’s blog! The link directs you straight to that specific blog entry.